My Photo

Become a Fan

Filmi Geek on Twitter

    follow me on Twitter

    « Pakeezah (1972) | Main | Filmi Geek metapost »

    January 30, 2007

    Comments

    Beth

    You haven't seen Koi Mil Gaya? Oh you must, it's so cute and sweet (normally terms that aren't my first choice for praise, but they fit here) and the dancing is even better. I'm having a hard time not putting my copy in an envelope to send you right this very second. I think you're right about the appeal of the Krishna character; you'll get the same sort of vibe in Koi Mil Gaya (and understand why "vibe" is the right word to use). Hrithik is very good at that kind of sweetness - for me, that component of his...acting style? personality? not sure what about him does it, but...anyway, that sweetness comes through in spades in his character in Lakshya, and I'd actually give that role the "most attractive male Bollywood character" runner-up prize (behind Sid, of course). He manages to be gentle and kind without being a fool (or being thought of as a fool by others), which I think is a type of person the world needs more of, that's for sure.

    I saw Krrish in Ahmedabad - so no subtitles - and I'd like to see it again. For the hair, if nothing else. Why has no one explored the connection of his fabulous tresses to his superpowers? I know there's precedent for that somewhere....

    carla

    I wasn't sure about *Koi mil gaya* but I'll add it to the list on your recommendation. I do know that even during *Krrish* I was impressed by Hrithik's portrayal of Rohit - I don't know whether it was flashbacks to KMG or new footage, but either way I liked the way Rohit was just as open and innocent as Krishna and yet not exactly the same as Krishna. I also haven't seen *Lakshya*, just the song "Main aisa kyun hoon" which I LOVE. I feel that I don't watch enough recent movies so I'll keep that one in mind as well. (My stack of DVDs waiting to be watched is almost all oldies.)

    Beth

    I think you'll enjoy it. There's a great dance with Hrithik and Preity in the rain - splashing and wire work. Lakshya is largely forgettable with a few exceptions, and that song is of course the major exception and might be the best dance in Bollywood ever (according to me, anyway).

    If only we could have a movie get-together! You can show me the oldies I'm missing and I'd do the same for the recenties!

    lemontart

    Krrish and Koi Mil Gaya are two of my favorites for feel-good Bollywood movies. Hrithik does a great job with characters like this, and as Beth mentioned above displays many of the same qualities in Lakshya, which in my humble opinion is an underrated movie. If you do get a chance to watch it you definitely should!

    Daddy's Girl

    While I was generally quite underwhelmed by 'Krrish', I agree that Hrithik gives the character a nice sweetness - I didn't like it much at the beginning of the movie (it felt too much like stupidity to me), but in the second half I appreciated it a lot more.

    carla

    lemontart: Thanks for the comment and recommendations. Someone I met in real life yesterday also recommended *Koi mil gaya* so I will have to take a look at it soon - the recommendations of it are racking up.

    DG: I know what you mean about Krishna seeming stupid at the beginning of *Krrish*. I read it more as naive innocence, but it's not a far stretch to see it as stupidity.

    maxqnz

    I suppose the best thing about this review is that has reminded me of the value of surprise. Knowing that our tastes are often quite similar, and generally being able to use your reaction to a film as an indicator of my own likely reaction, I was completely floored by this review. I had actually skipped reading your reviews of films that I have not seen, because of the general harmony in our tastes, and my desire not to have the films spoiled for me. So when I read you praising a film that would score as 4/10 if I was feeling genrous, I was dumbstruck.

    I found the acting awful, the effects mediocre, and the climax a ghastly mish-mash grab-bag of spuerhero clichés from as many different films as the makers could squezze into 15 minutes. Some of the scenes in the early part of the movie were not too bad, especially the whole "bhoot" gag, but for me this was uninspired mediocrity that actually seemed to celebrate its own "meh"ness. I forgive Naseeruddin his appearance in it because I know that his real work doesn't pay the bills, but given the choice between watching this washed out, anaemic "SupermanmeetsBatmanmeetsSpidermanmeetsTheFlash" clone/ripoff and SRK's Badshaah, I'd pick the latter in a heartbeat. And that is saying something for me, not being a SRK fan. As for the review itself, all I can say is, "vive la différence!"

    carla

    Well, I haven't seen Baadshah - and don't plan to - but given the choice between rewatching Krrish, and watching most Western superhero movies, I'd probably pick Krrish. That's not because I think Krrish is very good, but rather because I really can't stand the typical dark, brooding story arc of the typical dark, brooding superhero. Oh, yes, being a superhero is soooo haaaaaaard, and your life is just sooooo troublllllllled, and your brooding is sooooo deeeeeeep. Feh. One of the pleasant surprises of Krrish was that it didn't fall into the trap of that particular cliche - it kept its hero innocent and sweet, even when everyone he knew was basically out to get him. And that, to me, is the Indian slant that made Krrish reasonably engaging.

    At any rate, it's not like I called it the best film ever - I put it in the "timepass" category - and I did note that it draws on a wide variety of superhero cliches. I don't think it's high art or a film I'm ever going to watch again. It just engaged me pleasantly for a couple of hours - from some films, that's all I ask.

    Let me put this another way. Since I am not a fan of the superhero genre, I don't have great expectations from a superhero film. The fact that *Krrish* held my attention at all - very few western superhero films do - earns it a positive review.

    And - thanks for stopping by - it's good to see familiar, er, faces? Handles? Sock-puppets? ;-) reading my reviews and leaving comments. Hope to see you again.

    maxqnz

    You really should give Badshaah a go. Spectacularly dumb, and utterly aware of the fact. As a self-spoof of his usual roles, it's better than Main Hoon Na. When you want a rest from the intensity and emotional depth of Shabana's work, put your brain to bed and watch Badshaah.

    Rohit Marfatia

    I would like to buy DVDs of available old movies. I request you to let me know about prices and mode of payment.
    Rohit T Marfatia
    River Palace
    Nanpura
    Surat 395001
    Phone+912612476442 Mobile:+919824151144

    Verify your Comment

    Previewing your Comment

    This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

    Working...
    Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
    Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

    The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

    As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

    Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

    Working...

    Post a comment